Teuer Furniture Harvard Case Solution & Analysis

Comparable Valuation Analysis

The parameters or the dimensions on which the companies are being compared are listed below;

  • Total assets
  • Cash flow from Assets
  • Sales growth
  • Asset Price/Cash flow assets
  • Asset price/adjusted net income
  • Asset price/sales
  • Equity price/net income

On the basis of the total assets held by the companies, it is being evaluatedthat the total assets of the nine companies are increasing year by year showing that the assetswhich are reported on the balancesheet of the companies tend to increase value of the companiesand ultimately benefit the operations of the business.

In addition to this, it can be noted that increased assets wouldgenerate cash flows, improve sales andreduces cost or expenses.

Another dimension is the cash flow from assets which is significantly important to determine the cash inflow generated from the assets. It is essential that the cash flow from assets must be positive, however the cash position of the company can be resulted from the investment losses or gains resulted from the cash or amount being spent on the investment in the capital assets includingequipment and plant.

Amongst all of the comparable companies, the companies having positive cash flow from assets are listed below;

  • Ethan Allen interiors Inc.
  • Haverty furniture companies
  • La-Z boy incorporated
  • Stanley furniture company
  • Tempur sealy international Inc.
  • William Sonoma Inc.

Thus, it is analyzed that the comparable firmsshould be those having positive cash flow from assets, sales growth, Asset Price/Cash flow assets,Asset price/adjusted net income, Asset price/Sales and Equity price/net income.

The companies having positive cash flow from assets are ETH, TPX and WSM.They have shown increasing total assets in the balance sheet, but ETH and TPX have decreasing growth in sales.

As the Teuer Furniture is having 24.0 times cash flow from assets, it can be compared with the companies thatgeneratedcash inflows from the investment in the capital assets. The companies are ETH, TPX and WSM.

In addition to this, the Asset price/adjusted net income of TPX and WSM can be compared with Teuer because their values are close to that of Teuer.  It can be seen that TPX and WSM represent earning of the business after deducting all costs or expenses, this in turn reflects the financial health of company as compared to other companies.

The price of share can be wisely compared with the revenue generated by the company. After analyzing the companies showing asset price/sales ratio, it is determined that TPX has high price to sales ratio as compared to other eight companies.

 

Lastly, if theequity price/net income ratio is higher of any company it shows that the investors would be expecting higher earnings growth in the forthcomingyears. After evaluating the companies on the basis of the price earnings ratio, it is analyzed that TPX have higher equity price/net income or price earnings ratio as compared to other companies, depicting the fact that the company is in strong financial position satisfying its investors through providing higher earnings growth.

Question No.03

Through using multiple approaches, the Teuer Company is valued. The set of companies that have been chosen on the basis of the certain dimensions are TPX and WSM. The relevant multiple and the price of share is calculated, which can be seen in appendix.

The multiples of the comparable selected companies do differ with the Teuer Company because the average of the comparable companies is taken. The asset price/cash flow assets relevant multiple is 28.59371556, asset price/ adjusted net income is 17.69970658, asset price / sales is 1.314988092 and equity price/net income is 17.13196692 of the comparable companies.

There is a difference in the valuation of multiple calculated through discounted cash flow approach because the valuation of multiple is performed of the comparable companies. The comparable valuation multiples are used to value both selected companies.

Even though, all of the nine stated companies exist in the home furnishing industry, it is analyzed that these companies differ across the number of potential dimensions and parameters.

Conclusion:

After taking into account all facts and figures, it is being analyzed that the comparable valuation multiple analysis is useful in order to value the firm on the basis of the four equally important multiples.

In addition to this, the sales growth of Teuer Company is increasing year by year but overall net income is decreasing due to the increasing portion of cost of goods sold.

Furthermore, the companies are chosen on thebasis of positivevaluation multiple providing a better picture of the financial health of the company. The chosen companies includeTPX and WSM.

Exhibit A:

Teuer Furniture Pro Forma Cash Flow Assets
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Sales 148,218     149,700.08     151,197.08     152,709.05     154,236.14     155,778.50     157,336.29
  - Costs -112,132   (114,374.95)   (116,662.44)   (118,995.69)   (121,375.61)   (123,803.12)   (126,279.18)
  - Taxes -14,434 -16166.4 -18106.4 -20279.2 -22712.7 -25438.2 -28490.7
Net income 21,651 19,159 16,428 13,434 10,148 6,537 2,566
  - Capital expenditure -2,229 -2451.5 -2696.6 -2966.3 -3262.9 -3589.2 -3948.1
  + Depreciation 1,450 1812.6 2265.8 2832.2 3540.3 4425.4 5531.7
  - Increase in NWC -8,365 18519.9 15997.4 13300.2 10425.3 7373.4 4149.9
Cash flow assets 12,508 37039.8 31994.8 26600.3 20850.5 14746.8 8299.9
Terminal value 33042 25461 18883 13204 8330 4183
TOTAL CFs 12,508 70,081 57,455 45,483 34,054 23,077 12,482
Asset value 227,602
Share value 30.23
Parameters:
  Asset discount rate 12.1%
  Long-term growth rate 3.5%
  Shares outstanding (K)         9,945

Exhibit B:

Firm Characteristic BSET ETH FBN HVT LZB RN STLY TPX WSM Teuer
Total assets Increasing Increasing Increasing Increasing Increasing Increasing Increasing Increasing Increasing Increasing
Cash flow from Assets Negative Positive Negative Positive Positive Negtaive Positive Positive Positive Positive
Sales growth Decreasing Decreasing (Increasing) Increasing Increasing Increasing Increasing Decreasing Increase Decrease
Asset Price/Cash flow assets NMF 23.024364 NMF 20.25663 9.082471 NMF 1.3065195 26.5579871 30.62944 24.0354
Asset price/Adjusted net income 4.293889 10.66978 NMF 21.4741 7.26204 NMF 0.907618 20.34137 15.058 13.8854
Asset price/Sales 0.415905 0.875948 0.142492 0.49033 0.53484 2.35883 0.300649 1.675567 0.95441 2.02835
Equity price/Net income 5.801178 11.53484 NMF 24.3376 9.01703 NMF 2.158163 17.60256 16.6614 13.8854

Exhibit C:

Multiples BSET ETH FBN HVT LZB RN STLY TPX WSM
Asset price/Cash flow assets NMF 23.0244 NMF 20.2566 9.08247 NMF 1.30652 26.558 30.6294 28.5937
Asset price/Adjusted net income 4.29389 10.6698 NMF 21.4741 7.26204 NMF 0.90762 20.3414 15.058 17.6997
Asset price/Sales 0.41591 0.87595 0.14249 0.49033 0.53484 2.35883 0.30065 1.67557 0.95441 1.31499
Equity price/Net income 5.80118 11.5348 NMF 24.3376 9.01703 NMF 2.15816 17.6026 16.6614 17.132

 

This is just a sample partical work. Please place the order on the website to get your own originally done case solution.

Share This

SALE SALE

Save Up To

30%

IN ONLINE CASE STUDY

FOR FREE CASES AND PROJECTS INCLUDING EXCITING DEALS PLEASE REGISTER YOURSELF !!

Register now and save up to 30%.