Baer v. Chase Law Case Case Solution And Analysis, HBR Case Study Solution & Analysis of Harvard Case Studies

Baer v. Chase Law Case Case Study Solution

More of it, the quasi contract are applied for the purpose of compensation of novelty of idea, but in this case, the ideas presented by the Robert Baer to David Chase are the non-novel one which do not meet the requirement to compensate plaintiff under the rules and regulations of New Jersey law. Here, in the absence of the novelty and concreteness in the idea, the plaintiff cannot claim the defendant to enrich them, because the defendant has used an idea which already has been used before, and defendant has the right to use it freely.

Holding of the Case

Affirmed:To confirm a former law or judgment.
Reversed:To set aside; to annul.
Remanded:To scud a criminal back to custody after first hearing, to be kept until the hearing is resumed or the trial comes on.
Modified:To change or alter
Vacated:To annul; to render an act void;
Defendant:The person defending himself by denying the allegations.
Plaintiff: The person who sue someone.
Doctrine: A rule, principle, theory, or tenet of the law.
Quasi-contract: A determination by a court about the obligation of one party to another.
Implied contract:An oral agreement.
Express contract:A written agreement.
Novelty: An objection to a patent or claim for a patent on the ground that the invention is not new or original is called an objection “for want of novelty.”(Unknown, 2019)

Fairness of Court Decision:

As it has been explained above that the quasi contracts are applied for the purpose of compensation of novelty of an idea but in this case, the idea presented by the Robert Baer to David Chase is a non-novel one which does not fulfil the requirement to compensate the plaintiff under the rules and regulations of New Jersey law. Here, in the absence of the novelty and concreteness in the idea, the plaintiff cannot claim the defendant to enrich them because the defendant has used an idea which has been already used, and defendant has the right to use it freely.

Moreover, the services provided by the Robert Baer to the David Chase do not reflect its true value, because in verbal or oral contract (implied in fact contract), the parties have not mentioned the amount that how much is going to paid or received from this activity,which is why, the contract is not reflecting its true value and will not be entertained to be claimed for enrichment by the side of plaintiff form defendant.

Furthermore, in the verbal or oral contract (implied in fact contract), there were not any discussion or agreement related to the meaning of the word success. The discussion between Robert Baer and David Chase reflected an oral agreement on the payment of the value of Robert Baer services only on the success of the show, but the meaning of the word success are not defined in this communication,which is why the word success makes this implied in fact contract vague and cannot proceed further.

Moreover, the claims made by Robert Baer on David Chase contain the lacking in the essential terms of the contract which do not show the issue of material fact to be genuine. In this case, the judgment summary grant by the judge under the section 56 C of FRCP rules includes the pleadings of the case, depositions of the case progress, affidavits if they are available, all the case interrogations and admissions on file. All of these facts have not provided the genuine issue on material facts, which concludes that the implied contract is vague, which lacks the essential terms to be enforced while making the contract between two parties.

Above mentioned facts show that the decision made by court is full and fair, because the claims made by Robert Baer on David Chase are weaker than the justifications made by the defendant; David Chase……….

This is just a sample partical work. Please place the order on the website to get your own originally done case solution.

How We Work?
Just email us your case materials and instructions to order@thecasesolutions.com and confirm your order by making the payment here